About UsWine ReviewsArchivesAdvertiseContact Us


Posted by Robert Whitley on April 28, 2017 at 10:46 AM

Bordeaux 2016: The Right Bank

BORDEAUX, France — The warm, dry summer of 2016 provided ideal conditions for an excellent grape harvest throughout the Bordeaux region.

The Right Bank, planted heavily with merlot and cabernet franc, was no exception. The merlot in Pomerol delivered outstanding color and concentration, as did the merlot and cabernet franc of Saint-Emilion. Even the few plots of cabernet sauvignon that typically struggle to ripen in the cold clay and limestone soils east of the river Gironde matured to perfection.

The quality of the vintage was exceptional, and the yields were bountiful, a welcome gift for the Bordelaise, who are all too familiar with so-called "off" and often "short" vintages. Vintage 2016 has the whole of Pomerol and Saint-Emilion smiling.

The Right Bank is a large area with many satellite appellations that produce excellent wines in good years, but my evaluations are based upon the selection of wines presented by the Union des Grands Crus de Bordeaux, or UGCB, at its annual en primeur tastings, the coming-out party each spring for the new wines from the previous year.

The wines presented by the UGCB represented producers of Saint-Emilion grand cru and a number of top chateaux from Pomerol, which has no classification system. There is worldwide interest in the quality of these wines because many are offered for sale as futures — to be delivered when the wines are ready for commercial release in a couple of years. Futures prices are generally lower than release prices two years hence, when the quality of the vintage has been firmly established and demand is at its peak. Futures prices for the 2016 vintage have not yet been announced.

For the purpose of this report, my focus is on the more affordable wines presented at the UGCB tastings, not the prohibitively expensive wines of star chateaux, such as Cheval Blanc, Petrus, Ausone and their ilk. That is not to imply the wines evaluated are not expensive. They are but less so than the trophy wines hunted down by well-heeled collectors and speculators.

I use a four-point range when evaluating barrel samples, due to the volatility and fragility of young wines that have yet to be bottled. I look for color, concentration, balance, quality of tannins and overall potential based on more than 35 years of experience with very young and very old Bordeaux.

My personal assessment of the 2016 vintage in Pomerol and Saint-Emilion is very high, with the caveat that I believe the Left Bank is slightly more consistent. I attribute much of the difference to the obsession with new oak in Saint-Emilion, which can be a flaw if it either overwhelms the fruit or imparts astringent wood tannins, which can influence a wine throughout its lifespan, however long that may be.

That said, there were many stunning wines produced on the Right Bank in 2016, and overall, the wines of Saint-Emilion grand cru were more successful than those of Pomerol. The following are my personal recommendations.

Saint-Emilion Grand Cru

Chateau Canon La Gaffeliere — Good concentration, richness and length on the palate without being overextracted. Could blossom well. Good long-term potential. 90-93.

Chateau Dassault — Excellent concentration, pretty red fruits, integrated tannins, suave elegance. Outstanding long-term potential. 91-94.

Chateau La Dominique — Good concentration, complexity of black and red fruit, elegant tannins. Excellent long-term potential. 90-93.

Chateau Grand Mayne — Pretty wine with a suave palate. Good concentration. Integrated tannins. Complex layers of fruit. Excellent long-term potential. 93-96.

Chateau La Tour Figeac — Rich and bold, with fleshy ripe fruit and firm tannins. Exceptional long-term potential. 94-97.

Chateau Troplong Mondot — Excellent concentration, dense and rich, with firm tannins. Black and red fruits. Excellent long-term potential. 93-96.


Chateau Beauregard — Suave and rich on the palate, with good concentration and supple tannins. Exceptional long-term potential. 91-94.

Chateau Le Bon Pasteur — Fleshy but with firm structure. Nice plum notes. Very good medium-term potential. 88-91

Chateau La Cabanne — Red fruits, concentrated, with bold and aggressive tannins. Very good medium-term potential. 89-92.

Chateau Clinet — Fleshy fruit on the palate with firm tannins. Excellent structure and balance. Very good medium-term potential. 88-91.

Follow Robert on Twitter at @wineguru.

Decoy, Sonoma Valley (California) Sauvignon Blanc 2015 ($20)
Crisp without astringency, and fruity rather than herbaceous, this is an unpretentious and easy-to-drink Sauvignon Blanc.  It will enhance a variety of summery foods, from seafood salads to grilled shrimp or chicken.  I recently enjoyed the wine with roasted halibut topped with a fresh fennel-grapefruit salsa.
90 Marguerite Thomas

Dr. Michael
This Issue's Reviews
Lugana: The Perfect Summertime White
Michael Apstein

With their crispness and cutting acidity, the refreshing wines of Lugana, a small Denominazione Origine Controllata (DOC) on the southern edge of Lake Garda in northern Italy's Lake District, are perfect for drinking in the summer--or year round for that matter. (Just don't confuse Lugana, the wine, with Lugano, a neighboring lake.) A bonus is in finding an area that produces distinctive and unique wines using an autochthonous grape come to life, rather than succumbing to the allure of planting international varieties.
Q & A with Simonsig Estate's Johan Malan
Marguerite Thomas

Johan Malan is the winemaker at Simonsig Estate, located in South Africa's beautiful Stellenbosch region. Wine is surely in the Malan family's DNA, as Johan's ancestor, Jacques Malan, a French Huguenot, planted vines in 1688, soon after he arrived in the country. Johan's father, Frans Malan, planted vineyards in the foothills of the Simonsberg Mountain, which became the nucleus of today's Simonsig Estate. Today the estate is managed by Johan and his two brothers. I sat down recently with Johan to ask a few questions, and we continued this discussion later by email.
Wine With
WINE WITH…Orzo 'Rissotto' with Peas and Pancetta

This is the season when Italians take advantage of the first spring peas and go mad for risi e bisi. Since our reinterpretation of the classic dish calls for orzo instead of rice, you might call it 'faux risotto,' or perhaps 'orzotto.' But whatever the name, we think you'll agree that this makes a wonderfully tasty linchpin for a casual dinner, or even a first course for a more formal occasion. It is very easy to prepare, and requires a lot less stirring than real risotto. Furthermore, since barley takes about half as much time to cook as rice, our 'orzotto' goes from pan to plate in short order.
On My Table
Another Face of Sangiovese
Mary Ewing-Mulligan

Coastal Tuscany is a fascinating wine production area. It includes more than two dozen DOC or DOCG wine zones, many of which make very good red wines. Some of the zones, such as Bolgheri, rely on Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot while others make wines predominantly from Sangiovese, the grape that dominates the interior of Tuscany. Unlike in the interior, the Tyrrhenian Sea brings a Mediterranean climate, with warm, sunny, dry summers and cooling night temperatures. One of the areas that focuses on Sangiovese is the DOCG wine zone, Morellino di Scansano, situated around the town of Scansano in the southwestern corner of Tuscany, just east of the city of Grosseto. ('Morellino' in fact is a local synonym for Sangiovese.) Although it is not the smallest wine zone in coastal Tuscany, Morellino di Scansano is small; its predominantly hilly vineyards cover just 3,705 acres, which is less than half the size of the Brunello di Montalcino DOCG zone.