About UsWine ReviewsArchivesAdvertiseContact Us


Posted by Gerald D. Boyd on December 22, 2014 at 6:05 PM

“Wines of South America,” by Evan Goldstein MS

English-language wine books are everywhere, with new ones vying for coveted space on bookstore shelves.  Hardly a noted wine region hasn’t been covered in detail, except for South America.  Now, however, noted Master Sommelier Evan Goldstein has written “Wines of South America,” released by the prolific wine book publisher, University of California Press.

Goldstein takes the reader on a wine tour of 10 South American countries, including the best known:  Argentina, Chile, Brazil and Uruguay.  Who knew, though, that there are six other countries producing wine in South America?  Truth is, the six are really afterthoughts, since the real South American wine action, at least for North Americans, is coming from Argentina and Chile and maybe Brazil and Uruguay.  Still, the author should earn points for trekking to Paraguay to visit the country’s one winery that makes red wine from Grenache and Dornfelder, a German crossing that has had modest success in its native country.

Beyond Paraguay, Goldstein lists 94 other South American wineries, mostly in Bolivia, but also Colombia, Ecuador, Peru and Venezuela.  Bolivia’s total of 77 wineries is impressive until you realize that the bulk of the Bolivian grapes are intended for a different kind of grape drink  than wine.  “Only four of the country’s [Bolivia’s] nine departments have vineyards, and of their output, only half is intended for table wine,” says Goldstein.  “The balance is used to make singani,” known elsewhere in South America as pisco, a popular spirit with a Muscat base.

By comparison, Uruguay boasts 270 wineries, Brazil has 1,162 (Goldstein writes that only 160 are focused on fine wine), while Chile checks in with 240 wineries.  Argentina’s total of 1,320 wineries (approximately 370 are making fine wine), is the highest in South America.  The take away from all these gee-whiz umbers is that in South America, pisco and singani rule.  Of the thousands of wineries in South America, only a small percentage is exporting to North America and Europe.  But that shouldn’t stop the curious wine drinker who is looking for new experiences.

The long chapter on Argentina begins with Goldstein’s pick for “Argentinean Game Changers,” a short list that includes Susana Balbo (winemaker and owner of Dominio del Plata), Nicolas Catena (patriarch of Argentine wine and founder of Catena Zapata), Roberto de la Mota (developer of Terrazas de la Los Andes and Cheval des Andes) and Julio Viola, a real estate agent, grape grower, vintner and restaurateur, who few people outside of Argentina have heard about.  And there are region profiles with lists of recommended producers, followed by mini profiles of each winery.  Chile gets the same treatment, with Goldstein’s “Game Changers” including Alvaro Espinoza (the Carmenere champion), Maria Luz Marin (part of the vanguard of winemakers that opened the San Antonio area), Aurelio Montes (Montes and Montes Alpha wines) and Pedro Parra (Chile’s “terroir whisperer”). 

Grape detectives will find chapter 2 of interest.  The usual vinifera suspects (Chardonnay, Pinot Gris, Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot) are in most South American countries, but reading through the pages of this chapter my attention was drawn to red varieties Ancellotta (grown in Argentina and Brazil) and Arinaroa (Uruguay, Brazil and Argentina) and a small list of North American and hybrid grapes, including Concord, Isabella, Norton and Niagara, most of which are grown in Brazil.  A few grapes that started out in France but never gained interest there, such as Egiodola, are having modest success in Brazil and Uruguay, while the noted Tannat  grape of France’s Madiran has found a new home in Uruguay, Argentina and Brazil, with smaller acreage in Chile and Peru. 

Goldstein provides other thumbnail sketches of South American grapes but, for me, the most interesting story centers around Bonarda.  Argentina has more than 44,000 acres of Bonarda, making it the third most widely planted grape in that country.  Fans of Italian Piedmont reds are familiar with the Bonarda grape, but Goldstein notes that the Bonarda of Argentina is not the same as the Bonarda of Piedmont.  “It’s a different variety,” says Goldstein.  “Argentinean Bonarda is what the French call Douce Noir (from the Savoie region) and what the rest of the world calls Corbeau, except in the United States, where we call it Charbono.

At the back of the book, not listed in the Contents as appendices or chapters, is a handy section on wine traveling that includes recommended wineries and why you should visit them (restaurant, artisan cheeses, caves, etc.), a short section on “Dining South American Style,” and more lists of wines, this time sorted by variety. 

“Wines of South America” is not a glossy coffee table wine book; it has only a handful of snapshot-size black and white photos and 10 black and white maps that lack detail.  And while it is not as small as a handbook, “Wines of South America” is a handy guidebook you can throw into your backpack or suitcase as a ready reference when traveling the wine roads of South America.

“Wines of South America: The Essential Guide,” by Evan Goldstein, hardcover, 306 pages, ISBN: 9780520273931

*     *     *

Wine Review Online Columnist Emeritus Gerald Boyd contributes book reviews in this space on a regular basis from his so-called “retirement.”

Pascual Toso, Mendoza (Argentina) Barrancas Vineyards “Magdalena Toso” 2011 ($87, TGIC Importers)
A collaborative effort of Paul Hobbs and Rolando Luppino, this wine shows the possibilities of Mendoza and what can be done blending Malbec with other grapes to give it depth and character.  Blended with 40% Cabernet Sauvignon, this fully extracted wine shows brooding blackberry and black cherry fruit, with dusty minerality, brown spice and vanilla notes lending complexity to this very powerful and complex new world expression.  I’d serve this with strong cheeses, or let it stand alone.
94 Rich Cook

Dr. Michael
This Issue's Reviews
Seven Killer Champagnes to Finish Off the Year
Michael Franz

I don't know more than a handful of people who don't love Champagne, yet I'm often surprised by how few people really appreciate its greatness as a wine. Indeed, many casual consumers don't think of Champagne as wine at all, regarding it rather as a top-shelf rendition of a distinct beverage category including everything with bubbles…including Mimosas. For my part, I think that Champagne may be the best of all wines, with great renditions offering levels of complexity and age-worthiness that top bottles of Burgundy and Bordeaux can match--but rarely surpass. If you've yet to taste a wine that has led you to think of Champagne as playing in that league, here are seven examples that might do the trick.
Getting More from Loess
Wayne Belding

Loess soils are found throughout the world, comprising nearly ten percent of the earth's soil surface. These widely distributed soils are of interest to winelovers because they are the underpinning of several famous and highly desired wines. We find references to loess and wine most commonly in Austria, Germany, Hungary and the western United States. Loess (Löß in its native German) means 'loose' -- a reference to the poorly compacted nature of the soil. Loess is, in geologic terms, a recent deposit of windblown silt. Silt particles are very small -- 0.002 to 0.063 millimeters in diameter. That's 100 times smaller than your average beach sand grain size, so it's easy to see how silt particles can be transported by strong winds.
Wine With

Posole has been associated with holidays and celebration since the pre-Columbian days of human sacrifice. In our own era, posole (the name of the dish itself and of the soft, chubby kernels of white corn that play a starring role in it) is linked to feasting on Christmas Eve in both New and Old Mexico. No human sacrifice is involved, and pork and chicken have become the traditional ingredients. Chicken or pork, pork or chicken? We were making posole recently and couldn't decide between the chicken breasts or the pork belly that were tucked away in our freezer. Then we realized the obvious answer was to use both. We made most of the dish a day ahead, first rubbing the pork belly with a mixture of ground fennel seed, salt and pepper. You can get posole (also known as hominy) in two forms: dried or canned. While the dried option is somewhat superior, with a firmer texture and more overt flavor, it does have to be reconstituted via an overnight soak and a longish simmer. We took the lazier, quicker route, opened a couple of cans, and the result was just fine.
On My Table
A Barolo Producer Worth Knowing
Mary Ewing-Mulligan

Such are the riches of the Barolo wine zone that even those of us who visit the area regularly can be delighted by the discovery of a producer with whom we are not already familiar. I discovered Attilio Ghisolfi's Barolos thanks to Kerin O'Keefe's comments in her new book, 'Barolo and Barbaresco' (University of California Press). This winery had not been anywhere on my personal list of top Barolo producers, but in that, I apparently was not alone: O'Keefe describes Attilio Ghisolfi as 'Yet another of Monforte d'Alba's little-known treasures that flies under the radar of the media…'. Tasting the three Ghisolfi Barolo wines that are currently available in the U.S., I found much to like.