HomeAbout UsWine ReviewsArchivesAdvertiseContact Us


Wine Columns

Wine Reviews

WineReviewOnline on Twitter

Critics Challenge

Distillers Challenge

San Diego Challenge

Sommelier Challenge


Winemaker Challenge

WineReviewOnline on Facebook

WineReviewOnline on Instagram

Don't Pity Poor Pinot Blanc
By Paul Lukacs
May 2, 2017
Printable Version
Email this Article

Poor Pinot Blanc.  It belongs to a very famous wine family, but its sibling, the rich, noble Pinot Noir, gets most of the acclaim these days.  Lush, lavish Gris has plenty of admirers too.  Pinot Meunier may not make the society pages all that often, but it comes from Champagne, and consequently lives a luxurious life.  Meanwhile, Blanc gets overlooked, if not forgotten altogether.

Yet, just as Cinderella entranced her Prince at the ball, Pinot Blanc shines when given the opportunity to perform at the dinner table.  A remarkably versatile white wine, it has the uncanny ability to pair well with a wide variety of foods.  When you try a first-class rendition, odds are that you’ll end up admiring, not pitying it.

The various Pinot grape varieties constitute a close-knit family.  They share the same DNA, but have mutated over the centuries so that they now come in different colors and offer different flavors.  Blanc is the most elusive of the brood.  Meunier (actually a child of Noir) gives depth to Champagne.  Gris can alternate between opulence, as in Alsace, and vivacity, as in Italy (where it’s known as Grigio).  But Blanc’s chief virtue is subtlety, something that too often can be misconstrued as a weakness.
The inherent finesse of good Pinot Blanc does make it less appealing than more showy wines (including its Pinot siblings) in cocktail lounges or bars.  In those settings, muscle rather than grace will make any wine stand out from the crowd.

Pinot Blanc’s nuanced character, however, is precisely what makes it such a good dinner companion.  Not only won’t it overwhelm whatever you’re eating, but the interplay with food actually tends to enhance its charms.  This is one wine that definitely tastes more compelling during a meal than either before or afterwards.

Pinot Blanc was first identified as a separate grape variety in Burgundy at the end of the nineteenth century.  Though some vines still are cultivated there, the grape is now planted more widely elsewhere.  It grows throughout eastern Europe, and has yielded some impressive results in Oregon; but the best wines come from Alsace in France, northern Italy (where its called Bianco), Austria and Germany (where it is known as Weissburgunder).

Even in those regions, however, Pinot Blanc all too often is treated as a workhorse, playing second fiddle to supposedly more glamorous white wine grapes such as Riesling, Chardonnay, and even Pinot Gris.  For consumers, however, the vine’s second-class status can be an advantage.  That’s because Pinot Blanc often offers good value, usually costing about a third less than a producer’s other wines.      

The taste of Pinot Blanc varies, depending upon where the vines are grown and how the wine is made.  In cooler regions its fruit flavors tend to resemble apples and pears.  In warmer ones they can seem more peachy.  In the winery, the use of oak barrels becomes a crucial factor.  Too much wood can obliterate the wine’s subtleties, but just the right amount can add an attractive spicy edge.

No matter the wine’s origin or the winemaker’s style, good Pinot Blanc invariably is medium-bodied.  Few white wine dishes overpower it, just as it won’t overwhelm even delicate seafood preparations.  The best examples augment their fruit flavors with mineral-tinged secondary ones and tight but not aggressive acidity.  They enhance a meal by complementing, not overshadowing the food.    

Here are ten wines worth trying.  They are listed in ascending order by price.  With warm weather just around the corner, you probably soon will be looking for new white wines to enjoy with dinner.  This year, don’t overlook Pinot Blanc.  There’s really nothing poor about it.

Villa Wolf, Pfalz (Germany) 2015 ($12):  Quite subtle, with autumn fruit flavors and excellent balance due to the crisp acidity that keeps everything in check.  Its youthful vivacity constitutes its charm.  (Imported by Loosen Bros USA)

Hugel “Cuvée les Amours,” Alsace (France) 2014 ($14) :  Always reliable and widely available, Hugel’s Cuvee des Amours is an excellent introduction to Pinot Blanc.  It’s full of apple and pear fruit flavors.  (Imported by Frederick Wildman)
Domaine Jean-Luc Mader, Alsace (France) 2014 ($16):  A fine value, full of crisp autumn fruit flavors, and ending with a long, satisfying finish.  All of this winery’s current offerings are very good and very attractively priced.  (Imported by Elite Wines)

Tiefenbrunner, Alto Adige (Italy) 2015 ($16):  Crisp and fresh, with citrus fruit flavors, a somewhat floral bouquet, and subtle herbal notes in the finish.  (Imported by Winebow)

René Barth “Vignoble de Bennwihr,” Alsace (France) 2014 ($18):  The most delicate of all the wines recommended here, this is a gentle, even gentile pinot blanc.  Drink it with lighter seafood or poultry dishes.

St. Innocent “Freedom Hill Vineyard,” Willamette Valley (Oregon) 2014 ($23):  Ripe peach and pear fruit flavors, followed by secondary notes of sweet spice.  Luscious, but dry and satisfying.

Alois Lageder “Haberle,” Trentino/ Alto Adige (Italy) 2014 ($25):  Lageder’s regular Pinot Bianco is quite good and costs about $15, but this Haberle bottling is even better, with a slightly honeyed character enhancing the bright but rich fruit.  (Imported by Dalla Terra)

Prieler Seeberg Burgenland (Austria) 2014 ($26):  A vibrant wine, full of apple-scented fruit with a distinctive mineral-tinged and almost smoky undertone.  My guess is that it will taste even better in a year or two.  (Imported by Skurnik Wines)

Domaine Weinbach “Réserve” Alsace (France) 2015 ($22):  An aromatically more complex rendition than the less costly Alsatians recommended above, this wine offers similar fruit flavors but enhances them with a bouquet reminiscent of sweet honeysuckle and spring flowers.  (Imported by Vineyard Brands)

Cantina Terlan “Vorberg” Reserva Alto Adige (Italy) 2014 ($36):  Apricots, peaches, and more form a veritable fruit salad of aromas and flavors, enhanced by floral notes and a mineral-rich finish.  A stunning wine!  (Imported by Banville Wine Merchants)