HomeAbout UsWine ReviewsArchivesAdvertiseContact Us


Whitley On Wine

Wine Review Online Radio

W.R. Tish

Leslie Sbrocco

International Wine Center

The Great Wines of America

Wine Style Book

Gold Medal Wines

New York Times 'The Pour'


Critics Challenge

San Diego International


WRO Wine Blog

July 10, 2020

A Promising New Player in the Walla Walla AVA: Echolands Winery

New wineries get established pretty regularly in the New World, but I’m much less regular about actually reading the press releases about them.  Something about a new venture needs to catch my eye, or I’m entirely content to wait to taste whatever comes of it, however long the interim.  In this instance, however, something caught my eye in the press release, and then the debut wine caught my fancy the next week, so here we go:

What caught my eye was the involvement of one of the best minds in wine…Doug Frost, MW & MS…getting ready to launch a Syrah from Walla Walla from a venture in which he is a principal.  Full disclosure:  Doug has been a friend for roughly two decades, and though we only see one another occasionally, when you’re a journalist writing about someone with whom you’ve enjoyed multiple meals on at least three continents and in your own home--you’d better come clean.

With that noted, the soon-to-be released 2018 Syrah (already on offer through the website) will convince you that my interest in this project wasn’t skewed by friendship.  Before addressing that wine, here’s a brief outline of the Echolands enterprise.  Frost is CEO, his fellow resident of Kansas City, Brad Bergman is Chairman, Taylor Oswald is Winemaker and Sadie Drury is Vineyard Manager.  They purchased their own vineyard on the Oregon side of the Walla Walla AVA in 2017, prepped it for two years, and planted in 2019.  We’ll see when they decide that fruit from their estate vineyard is ready to roll, but for now, they’re working with fruit from the highly-regarded Les Collines and Seven Hills Vineyards.

The lineup will include Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Cabernet Franc, Petit Verdot and Grenache, in addition to Syrah.  It is easy enough to piece together the intended style of the wines from the website: objectives include freshness and nerve, moderate oak, fidelity to a single appellation, and ability to age.  You’ll enjoy learning more if you consult the Echolands website, which expresses these objectives without getting preachy, and describes the venture in a way that doesn’t seem self-important—a fact that will come as no surprise to readers who know Doug.

The 2018 Syrah will set you back all of $38, though it performs well above that price, serving thereby as an object lesson in the serious-but-not-self-important ethos of the project. 

I particularly admire this wine as a lover of wines from the northern Rhône, which are also dear to Doug’s heart.  What is most distinctive about those wines—and most often missing from their Syrah counterparts from other parts of the world (emphatically including the USA) is bright acidity and a sense of freshness.  The first release shows both of those characteristics in spades, without any of bland “muddiness” or monolithic character that marks so many New World renditions. 

It features red berries up top, along with some very faint wood notes (much more about spice than toast, let alone smoke), and some darker fruit tones show up in the midpalate before the bright red notes re-assert themselves in the finish, which is pleasantly tart and very long…and pure. 

As noted above, the winery website addresses ability to benefit from aging as an objective.  Having tasted a press sample of a debut vintage of a wine that’s still to be released, I’m obviously extrapolating when assessing the 2018 in that respect.  However, trying any young wine again after sloshing it around and leaving it open for 24 hours is a pretty telling test of age-worthiness, and this wine…did not budge an inch over that span. 

That’s an especially important attribute for New World Syrah, because it suggests that with time to develop tertiary characters from bottle aging, an ultra-pure wine like this can develop the savory characters that other Rhône-style aspirants only “achieve” by means of deliberately dirty winemaking.  We need not dwell on that, as the upshot here is clear:  This is a wine to buy and age and try at different points in its development.  It is already delicious…but I am confident that it will get much better.  I scored it at 93 Points, and recommend it enthusiastically.
Posted by Michael Franz at 4:46 PM

July 2, 2020

4 Sparklers for the 4th of July and beyond

I've selected four all-American bubblies, two in what I would describe as the top tier of sparkling wine in the United States and two that I would describe as exceptional value bubblies that over deliver in relation to price.

Always high on my list of top-tier sparklers are the Domaine Carneros Brut Rosé  ($44) and the J Vineyards Cuvee 20 ($45). 

The current release of the Domaine Carneros brut Rosé  is from the 2016 vintage.  

The J Cuvee 20 is a superb multi-vintage brut that shows off the potential for bubbly made in the Russian River Valley, where Pinot Noir and Chardonnay reign.  You really can't go wrong with either of these beauties.

On the value side, the non-vintage Korbel Blanc de Noirs ($13.99) is a gem and probably the most consistent of all the Korbel sparklers, which, in general, are exceptionally consistent.

Then there is a newbie (at least to me) called Bash! sparkling Rosé  ($13.99).  It comes with a generic "California" appellation, and it was a surprise gold-medal winner at the recent San Diego International Wine & Spirits Challenge.   

And there you have it: your very own July 4th fireworks in a bottle!

Posted by Robert Whitley at 12:14 AM