About UsWine ReviewsArchivesAdvertiseContact Us
Querciabella, Toscana IGT (Tuscany, Italy) “Batàr” 2020 ($130, Maison, Marques & Domaines)
 A rare Tuscan white that can stand bottle shoulder to bottle shoulder with its pricey red siblings.   A blend of Chardonnay and Pinot Bianco, it is about as exotic and tropical as you will get for a Chardonnay and as upper-crusty as you will achieve from a fairly warm climate Pinot Bianco.  It is like sipping a fine whiskey as you try to dissect its flavor strands – floral like honeysuckle, but some green floral undernotes, some oak barrel spiciness, and only a hint of apple, Chardonnay’s go-to comparison.  It is fullish and textured without being heavy – a rare Tuscan treat.            
94 Roger Morris


Posted by Michael Franz on April 17, 2024 at 4:23 PM

Better Wine for Free: Think Temperature as Weather Heats Up

Gone are the days when heat was an issue in relation to wine only during summer.  With many locations around the world now seeing all-time high temperature averages rising year after year, heat is now an issue during spring as well.  I live just outside Washington, DC, and our first 80-degree days hit before Tax Day on April 15.  So, what used to be advisable for wine lovers during the summer months has already kicked in.  My word “advisable” is really not sufficiently strong, as it is actually imperative that you adjust your practices if you want to derive maximum enjoyment from the wines you buy this time of year.

We should start with red table wines because this is the type most frequently treated in a less-than-optimal manner—even by longstanding wine lovers.  Many of us grew up learning the rule of thumb that “red wines should be served at room temperature.”  Well, that might have made sense when some guy in an English manor house hatched the idea in the 18th century, prior to the advent of central heating, air conditioning, or the recent round of climate change.  These days, that’s often quite bad advice.

For example, if you’d been in DC during one of those recent 80-degree days, odds are that you had your windows open (makes sense after being cooped up during winter), and with a torrid DC summer approaching, you’d probably be unwilling to turn on the air conditioning.  That means that “room temperature” at 6 p.m. was probably about 75.  In turn, that means that a bottle of red wine teed up earlier in the day for serving with dinner is fully 10 degrees warmer than the temperature at which it would taste best.

Reds that are too warm will show too much alcoholic “heat” in their aromas and aftertaste, and will seem soupy and unfocused, with insufficient acidity and almost no refreshment value.  When the weather gets really hot (meaning, anywhere in the 90s), I chill every red that I taste (whether for review or for fun) into the refrigerator for 20 to 30 minutes before opening.  Last week in DC, you wouldn’t have needed half an hour in the fridge to get your red set for success, but 15-20 minutes would have made it considerably better.

White and sparkling wines are mishandled less often in my experience as a guest in the homes of others or in restaurants, but most people could get better performance from these wine types (without any additional expense) by being more thoughtful and even experimenting a bit.

I know experts on Champagnes and sparkling wines who dispense what I believe to be bad advice.  And to be clear, I mean real experts—not just self-appointed “man-splainers”—who advise consumers to “fully chill” sparkling wines, even to the point of full immersion in ice buckets.  My experience indicates that this is bad advice—and demonstrably bad advice at that.  A bottle of "fully chilled" Champagne shows much less aromatic complexity than one that has been pulled from a refrigerator for 20-25 minutes, and also seems more tart, with less breadth on the palate and fewer flavor complexities.

This is a fact, and you can test it yourself with ease for free.  If you’re hosting a dinner or event for which you’ll need two bottles of bubbly, simply begin by chilling them both for hours ahead of time at your refrigerator’s normal temperature.  Then, pull one out and set it on the counter (assuming your room temperature is around 70 or 71 degrees).  Set a timer on your phone for 22 minutes, and then open and pour that bottle as well as the one that you’ve just pulled from the refrigerator.  I’m utterly confident that you’ll find more complexity and derive more pleasure from the bottle that was pulled earlier, and it makes no difference if the two identical bottles are Champagne, Prosecco, Cava, Franciacorta, or any other type of sparkling wine.

You don’t even need a party to do this.  If you have one or two effective sparkling wine stoppers, you can simply stopper up one of the bottles, stick it back in the fridge, and enjoy it later in the week (or even during the following week; sparklers are phenomenally durable if you’ve got good stoppers for them).

Knowing that, you could usefully expand this experiment by using any kind of bucket to really ice down a third bottle, as is often done in restaurants or at outdoor parties served by caterers.  Keep that third bottle on ice until some of it melts and there’s nearly as much water as ice in the bucket, then pull one bottle out of your fridge for the 22 minutes, and then open all three after your alarm sounds.  You will agree that the iced bottle is the least expressive, followed by the one just pulled from the refrigerator (which will finish 2nd), and that the bottle that was allowed to warm a bit is the best of the bunch.

Everything just noted about sparkling wines holds true for white table wines without bubbles, so our work is nearly done.  Even in summer, I would never serve (or review) a white wine that I hadn’t pulled from one of my refrigerators for less than 20 minutes.  (And yes, that plural is correct:  I have three refrigerators, two of which are devoted to wine, with the 3rd devoted to preserving my marriage.)

The only exception to my advice for whites and sparklers is if you’re going to take the bottles outside to serve on a patio or on an outdoor table on a warm-to-hot evening.  In that case, you should not let the wine warm up quite so much as I just advised before serving, for the following reason:  If you and your guests will be enjoying a glass for, say, 12 minutes from start to finish, the point at which the temperature should be perfect would be the sixth minute--not the first.  If you or a friend find the wine too cold when it is first served, the situation can be remedied by cupping it in one’s hand for 20 seconds.  By contrast, it is much more difficult to deal with a glass that goes warm once it has been served.

I don’t wish to come off as being overly cocky, but what you’ve read is less a matter of personal preference than it is the flat-out truth.  Of course, it is possible that you have personal preferences that over-ride a professional taster’s seasoned sense of the temperature at which wines are at their best.  What should you do then?  Whatever you please.  The only point of wine is pleasure, and it is your pleasure that counts!

Dr. Michael
This Issue's Reviews
Deceptively Soft Spoken Zind-Humbrecht: Looking Back to the Fine 2016s
Panos Kakaviatos

June 12, 2024: Readers should keep in mind that, too often, consumers drink fine whites of Alsace too young. Looking back to a vintage nearly eight years old in bottle makes sense, as only now are most of the wines reviewed below beginning to enter an early drinking window. Known to produce some of the best Alsatian wines sold in both France and in international markets, Domaine Zind-Humbrecht also offers a 'bird's eye' view of each vintage in a well-organized tasting along with detailed vintage reports. A mild and wet winter and spring allowed for a fertile bud break, but also caused disease problems (mildew). Summer and the ripening period to the harvest were arid and warm. 2016 thus strangely combines the characteristics of an early- and late-ripening vintage.
What Is It About Tuscany?
Andrew Holod

June 12, 2024: Tuscany as a region seems to have entered the psyche of Americans and refused to leave. There are so many factors which contribute to the popularity of Tuscany and its centrality in how Americans think of Italy and Italian wine. The region is pinned to the map by the important cities of Florence and Siena, with Rome just a bit farther south. It offers picturesque rolling hills, dotted with stone villas (that seem to have inspired many a Napa winery), towering cypress and olive trees, and vineyards as far as the eye can see. Combine those indelible images along with the historical fiaschi (plural of a fiasco, which initially were straw-wrapped bottles, not a group of small disasters), which seem like a cultural echo for modern wine drinkers, even if they have never imbibed from this classic bottle shape. Finally, the wine regions themselves, which are some of the most famous in Italy: Chianti and its higher quality Classico brother, Brunello and Rosso di Montalcino, Vino Nobile and Rosso di Montepulciano, the "Super Tuscans" of Bolgheri and Maremma...and the list goes on.
Wine With
WINE WITH…Spaghetti Pure & Simple

March 27, 2024: I find myself gravitating towards simpler food, fewer meat-oriented menus, and in general focusing more on simplicity rather than complexity. Simple pasta, for example, is something I've been craving recently. What my palate longs for instead is simple, spaghetti-type pasta, but I want the noodles to be sauced with nothing more, really, than a drizzle of olive oil. Perhaps I'll garnish this simple dish with something raw, and green, and crunchy.
On My Table
Happy Surprises from a Local Harlem Wine Shop
Mary Ewing-Mulligan

May 7, 2024: Within my household, I am the wine scholar - educator, wine school owner, Master of Wine - but my husband is Monsieur le Sommelier. He buys the wine and collects wine, and I share the drinking. Recent circumstances have made me the sole wine drinker in the family and separated us from our large cellar to boot. Now I am a wine buyer. Short of time, I turned to my local wine shop in Harlem, The Winery, which is run by Eric White, a former student of mine who has done me proud. It's a small shop that by necessity offers carefully chosen wines from a thoughtful taster. I have had no end of delight in exploring its shelves. The following wines are a few examples.